Three Cheese Spread

This Cream Cheese Spread recipe is perfect for pairing with crackers! The perfect party snack and it’s easy to whip up with three different types of cheese for a creamy, cravable cheese spread that is so much better than the store bought version!

My husband used to request I buy tubs of cheese spread from the store, but now we just make this homemade version!

Cheese Is The Way To My Heart.

Have you seen those commercials that say “Ahh, the power of cheese?” Well, I don’t want to be weird or anything, but cheese! It is powerful.

Everyone loves it (and I don’t want to hear about it if you don’t!) which means it is the perfect food to serve at get-togethers, parties, funerals, weddings, baby showers, and late-night television watching marathons.

Just in case I forgot to mention a time when serving cheese would be appropriate, a good rule of thumb is this: If people will be present, cheese should be on the menu. Hallelujah and amen.

Our Cream Cheese Spread is made with three different types of cheese + a little scoop of mayo for the ultimate creamy goodness + loads of seasonings because we like flavor around here.

This keeps in the fridge quite nicely, so it’s perfect to make ahead or keep on hand for unexpected late night snacking.

♥ What We Love About This Recipe:

• Cheesy: This one is kind of obvious but we love all that cheese! With three kinds of cheese there is no shortage. And when you use freshly grated cheese it’s even better. This is the ultimate cheesy spread!
• Versatile: You can serve this cream cheese spread as an appetizer for game days, at events, or just when you need a snack. Plus, you can serve it with just about anything you’d like for dipping! Crackers, chips, veggies, you name it.
• Meltable: You think this is good as a cracker spread? Yes, you’re right – now try it sandwiched in a grilled cheese or dolloped on a hot burger. Oh my heavens.

Ingredient Notes:

Cheese – This dip is using a combination of sharp cheddar cheese, pepper jack cheese, and cream cheese. Start with room temperature cream cheese for easy mixing, and freshly grate the cheddar and pepper jack if possible.

Mayonnaise – We use real mayo here to add a touch more creamy goodness. If you use Miracle Whip, the cheese spread will have a hint of tangy sweetness to it. Either works!

Garlic – A freshly minced clove of garlic is a simple way to add lots of great flavor to the dip.

Herbs & Seasoning – You’ll need chopped fresh parsley, onion powder, salt, pepper, and red pepper flakes. The red pepper adds a little bit of spicy heat but not too much. You can use more or less to taste.

Worcestershire Sauce – It doesn’t take much of this to add savory flavor to just about anything and that includes this three cheese dip.

See the recipe card for full information on ingredients and quantities.

How to Make Three Cheese Spread:

Grate the cheddar and pepper jack cheeses into a large bowl. We highly recommend grating cheese from a block for the best flavor and texture.

Add all of the remaining ingredients including the cream cheese and stir well to combine. You can add more milk if you want a thinner consistency.

Spread this on crackers or serve it with chips or pretzels for dipping. This is also delicious melted into a grilled cheese sandwich or spread on top of a hot smashburger.

Variations:

This cheese spread is simple, tasty, and perfect for your next get together. Feel free to play with the flavors of this and make it your own.

I have a feeling that a bit of that powdered ranch dip mixed in would be quite tasty.

Swap the milk for beer and give it more of a beer cheese vibe.

Use any variety of cheese that you like! A smoky cheese adds a nice depth.

• Beer Cheese Dip
• Bacon Jalapeno Cheese Spread
• Cranberry Cream Cheese Dip
• Olive Dip
• Pimento Cheese Spread
• Bacon Ranch Cheese Ball
• Buffalo Chicken Cheese Ball